One of Canada’s largest newspapers just published what read a whole lot like an incitement to violence against NDP Leader Avi Lewis, prompting widespread condemnation.
Yet for some reason, there appears to be all but radio silence from mainstream Canadian media.
I searched all major news outlet’s websites and found that while all of them covered pro-Israel backlash to Lewis’ remarks about the genocide in Gaza (some with multiple op-eds) just three outlets published a six sentence story that mentioned the threatening column published in the National Post, days after the initial threat, and not even mentioning Lewis in the headline.
Instead, that headline read: “After arson attack, Liberal MP warns violent rhetoric puts all MPs at risk.”
Now, a caveat: I’m writing this on Friday, October 2, and will be publishing it on Monday since I’m travelling for work that day. However, given the National Post op-ed has been online since Sept. 29, I feel pretty safe in voicing concern about the lack of coverage.
What the hell happened?
The op-ed in question, titled Yoni Goldstein: Jewish law tells us how to deal with Avi Lewis, opens with a story that the author says is a “stark lesson in how Jews think about internal dissent.”
The lesson, Goldstein writes, is that “when a Jew endangers the Jewish community, the community is obligated to stop them.” In the story he tells, that stoppage took the form of the dissenter and his entire family being “swallowed alive” by the earth, and all his supporters being “consumed by fire.”
Yes, this was actually published in one of the largest publications in Canada. It gets worse, too.
Later in the piece — after coyly saying it’s “not clear you can draw a straight line” between Lewis’ comment about the genocide in Gaza and a shooting that a reportedly far-right, anti-vaccine antisemite committed at a synagogue in Belleville that same day — Goldstein adds “but, on their own merit, Lewis’ comments endanger Jews everywhere in Canada.”
The op-ed argues that when a Jewish person “presents a clear and present danger to the Jewish community,” “private” and “honest” discussions are no longer enough.
“When that happens, Jewish thought is much more forceful: you must prevent the perpetrator from causing harm,” Goldstein wrote.
Lest there be any misunderstanding about precisely what he meant, Goldstein then explains that when a Jew is a “rodef,” or “actively pursuing another with the intent to harm or kill them,” the law is clear that “a Jew is duty-bound to step in.”
The implication, to me, appears to be that Lewis is this “rodef.” That’s the same label that was lobbed at former Israeli prime minister Yitzhak Rabin during the Oslo accord negotiations of the 1990s, repeatedly, until an extremist used the term to justify assassinating Rabin.
That is what the National Post published, which is fucking unhinged.
Okay but what did Avi Lewis say?
So what did the NDP leader dare to say to deserve this fate for himself, his family and all his supporters? Well, on Yom Kippur — a day of atonement for the Jewish community — Lewis posted his personal reflections, as a Jewish man.
“Tonight Yom Kippur begins, the most sombre moment of the Jewish calendar. It’s a time of atonement - a time to grieve those who have been lost, a time to acknowledge and take responsibility for harms we have caused, individually and collectively,” he wrote on Twitter.
“For Jewish people, the personal has always been political and the political always personal. This year I'm reflecting on the fact that we failed to do our part to stop an ongoing genocide committed in our name. There are many other fronts where I have to do the work of repair. But nothing on this scale.”
The backlash was swift. Op-eds and tweets from pro-Israel voices quickly claimed he was collectively blaming Jewish people for the genocide in Gaza — a willful misreading of what Lewis said.
He explicitly said “our part,” implying everyone has a part to do. He highlighted that the genocide is being committed in the name of his community, and lamented that he and his community — like everyone else — failed to do their part to stop it.
Lest there be any confusion, Lewis clarified his statement in response to reporter questions. During a press conference the day the Liberals introduced a bill that unions say attacks the right to strike and that environmentalists say will bulldoze nature, the media asked the most prominent progressive politician in Canada about what really matters: bad-faith outrage in response to one of his tweets.
“I did not blame Jews for the actions of the Israeli government, that’s simply untrue. Holding Jews collectively responsible for the actions of the state of Israel is antisemitic. I’ve never done it. I think it’s dangerous, and that’s absolutely not what I did,” he told journalists on Sept. 21.
“I spoke as a Jewish Canadian from a place of profound sadness on the day of atonement and a day of the deepest and most solemn reflection in our calendar, and said what many, many Jews feel, and many Jews have said: that we have not done enough as Jewish people among a family of faiths and communities around the world. Humanity has not done enough to stop an ongoing genocide in Gaza.”
Lewis added that he’s “not going to police how other people reflect on Yom Kippur.”
“I think it’s pretty ugly to see (…) this occasion being used to score partisan points. That, I won’t be doing that. That was a personal reflection that I know is shared by many people.”
The backlash and the silence
While Lewis’ tweet seems pretty cut and dry to me — especially given his later explanation, Canadian media latched onto the story and wouldn’t let go (at least, until it came time to cover an op-ed that arguably threatened Lewis and his family’s lives).
The Toronto Star, CBC News, CTV News and the Canadian Press all published stories on the criticism Lewis faced for his Yom Kippur reflections. The Globe and Mail published two op-eds and an editorial board reflection all linking Lewis’ comments to the Belleville shooting, despite no evidence that the shooter held anti-Zionist beliefs and plenty of evidence he held far-right ones.
In fact, Robyn Urback — author of a Globe and Mail op-ed arguing Lewis’ comments “should be disqualifying,” has mocked the idea that Canadian Jewish people should be concerned about far-right extremism in an exchange with me on Twitter.
“The amusing thing about this exchange is the implication that Canadian Jews are worried about neo-Nazis at the moment,” she said.
Meanwhile, the National Post has published no fewer than four separate pieces on Avi Lewis’ comment.
A fascinating note about the National Post, which we as Canadian taxpayers subsidize, by the way, is that its Editor-in-Chief Rob Roberts went on a paid trip to Israel sponsored by an organization called the Exigent Foundation. That group has flown several Canadian journalists out for these trips. The organization was co-founded by a former Canadian ambassador to Israel who also worked for Black Cube, an Israeli intelligence firm.
Yeah, the National Post is not a serious publication.
What’s fascinating, though, is that all this coverage of Lewis being “criticized” for his Yom Kippur post focused on just two critical tweets. Both were from Liberal MPs.
Interestingly, multiple MPs have also criticized the National Post op-ed. Liberal MP Salma Zahid said it’s “hard to believe such an article was published,” adding that “This article should be withdrawn and (the National Post) should apologize.” NDP MP Don Davies called the piece “appalling, irresponsible and likely criminal.”
On top of that, seven major non-profits, including Independent Jewish Voices and Jewish Voice for Peace, have called for the federal government to stop subsidizing Postmedia if the National Post doesn’t take accountability for the article.
Despite all this, my search at 3:00pmET and another search at 5:15pmET on Friday Oct. 2 found not one article has been published about this criticism in the Globe and Mail, CBC News or the National Post.
Most major media outlets wrote about the bad-faith outrage that followed Lewis’ Yom Kippur message.
Few wrote a word about the target placed on his back by one of the largest outlets in the country — and those that did hid it behind an extremely vague headline.
An excerpt that’s stuck with me
I’m going to leave you with a powerful excerpt from Mohammed El-Kurd’s Perfect Victims. He explains how Israel constantly describes itself as acting on behalf of all Jews and doing all this in the name of Judaism — but when Palestinians voice what they’re constantly told, this ignorance is used to justify their suffering.
It is dangerous and wrong to conflate Israel and Judaism. Which is why Israel needs to stop doing it.
That’s why it feels so incredibly backwards to see all the headlines about Avi Lewis’ statement. We allow Israel to make this conflation, but viciously attack a Jewish man for considering, on a deeply personal day, what more he could have done to say “not in my name.”
Anyone criticizing Israel is expected to use the perfect words — and even when they arguably do, as I would suggest Lewis did in his statement, those words can still be twisted to mean something damning. When those words, in their twisted form, are then used to threaten the life of the speaker and their family, suddenly those who were so concerned about language fall all but silent.
Canadian media must do better.
—
“When we were growing up in occupied Jerusalem, the people seeking to expel us from our neighborhood were Jewish, and their organizations often had ‘Jewish’ in their name. So were the people who stole our home, scattered our furniture in the street, and burned my baby sister’s crib. The judges banging their gavels in favor of our expulsion were also Jewish, and so were the lawmakers whose laws systematized our dispossession. On some afternoons, I came home from school to find busloads of Jewish tourists in our front yard, pointing at us like animals at an auction, spitting American expletives in our faces. Some mornings, young-looking settlers would be shuckling in our garden, in their kippahs and tefillin. Others were older and secular: they wore khakis and sandals and did not pray much. Every couple of months, they would knock at our door and smirk as they handed my grandmother expulsion orders and court summons.”
(…)
“Though the settler colony’s Jewish character was no secret, we were still instructed to treat it as such, sometimes by our parents, other times by well-meaning solidarity activists. We were instructed to ignore the Star of David on the Israeli flag and to distinguish Jews from Zionists with surgical precision. it did not matter that their boots were on our necks, and that their bullets and batons bruised us. Our statelessness and homelessness were trivial; what mattered was how we spoke about our keepers, not the conditions they kept us under—burglarized, blockaded, surrounded by colonies and military outposts—or the fact that they kept us at all.
Language was more of a minefield than the border that separated the occupied Golan Heights from the rest of Syria, and we, children at the time, were expected to hop around the land mines, hoping we would not accidentally step on an explosive trope that would discredit us. Using the wrong words has the magical ability to make objects disappear; the boots, bullets, batons and bruises all become invisible if you say the wrong words, in jest or in fury. Even more dangerously, believing in the wrong things rendered you deserving of this brutality. Citizenship, self-determination, and the right to movement were not the sole privileges robbed from us; simple ignorance was a luxury as well.”
Mohammed El-Kurd, Perfect Victims and the Politics of Appeal, pg. 97-100.











